Myth: I Will Lose Control If I Eat What I Want

In a world filled with diets, food rules, and conflicting nutrition advice, it's easy to lose sight of what it means to have an actual healthy relationship with food. There are countless myths and misconceptions about eating, many of which lead us down a path of frustration and self-doubt. That’s why it’s important to shed light on one such myth that has held many people back from pursuing intuitive eating head on. That myth is: "I will lose all self-control if I allow myself to eat whatever I want, whenever I want." This belief often gets stuck in our minds as we make progress towards the principles of Intuitive Eating, particularly Principle 3: Make Peace with Food. But here we're going to put this myth to rest, and we're going to do it with science and compassion. Allowing yourself to eat without guilt or restriction doesn't lead to an uncontrollable spiral of indulgence. Instead, it leads to something called habituation, a process where our psychological and emotional response to frequently repeated foods neutralizes.

The Myth Exposed

The myth that often leaves many people feeling trapped and disempowered is the belief that if they allow themselves to eat whatever they want, whenever they want, they will completely lose control over their eating habits. This myth is closely tied to Intuitive Eating Principle 3: Make Peace with Food, which encourages individuals to grant themselves unconditional permission to eat.

Let's explore this myth further and reveal the truth behind it

The heart of this myth lies in the fear of losing self-control once you give yourself the freedom to eat without restrictions. It's a common concern, especially for those who have struggled with diets and food rules for a long time. The idea that you'll lose all self-control can be paralyzing. To understand this myth better, let's turn to the science of habituation. Habituation refers to the process where our psychological or emotional response to a frequently repeated stimulus diminishes over time. In simpler terms, the more you expose yourself to something, the less impactful it becomes. To illustrate this concept, consider a hypothetical scenario: Imagine you were told to eat only pizza and ice cream for every meal, for an entire week. Initially, the thought might sound exciting, even indulgent. But as the week progresses, you'd likely find yourself growing tired of these foods. By the end of the week, you might not want to look at pizza or ice cream for a while. This is habituation in action.

So then why do so many of us fear losing control when it comes to food? Diet culture plays a significant role in shaping these beliefs. For years, we've been bombarded with messages that our bodies need to conform to a certain, often unattainable, standard of beauty. We've been led to believe that the path to achieving this ideal is through strict restriction and following countless food rules. The reality, however, couldn't be further from the truth. Intuitive eating is about freeing yourself from these arbitrary food rules. It's about trusting your body's cues, cravings, and hunger signals. It acknowledges that, initially, you may overeat certain foods that you've been denying yourself for so long. But that feeling of loss of control diminishes as you practice unconditional permission to eat. Your body learns to trust you, and you learn to trust your body.

  

Habituation 

To debunk the myth that giving yourself unconditional permission to eat will result in a loss of all self-control, we need to look into the science of habituation. This psychological process is at the core of understanding why intuitive eating works and why you won't spiral into a never-ending cycle of binge eating.

Habituation is a term used in psychology to describe the process of a diminished psychological or emotional response to a frequently repeated stimulus. In simpler terms, it means that when you expose yourself more frequently to something you once considered forbidden or special, your response to it becomes neutralized. Imagine you're presented with your favorite food, something you've been denying yourself for a while. The initial excitement and craving are strong, and you might even eat a bit more than usual. But as you continue to enjoy this food regularly, your desire for it starts to wane. It's no longer the forbidden fruit; it becomes just another option among many.

When you first start practicing intuitive eating and give yourself unconditional permission to eat, you might find yourself overindulging in foods you've been restricting for a long time. It's completely normal, and it's part of the process. However, over time, as you continue to listen to your body and trust your cravings, that feeling of loss of control starts to dwindle. You begin to recognize that those once-enticing foods are just a part of your diverse diet, and you can enjoy them whenever you genuinely want them, without the fear of spiraling out of control.

In a nutshell, habituation, guided by the principles of intuitive eating, helps you regain a sense of balance and control around food. It's a journey that allows you to break free from the restraints of diet culture and embrace a healthier relationship with what you eat, and ultimately, yourself.

The Influence of Diet Culture 

For far too long, many of us have been unwittingly swayed by the relentless messages perpetuated by this culture, leaving us with misconceptions about our bodies and what it takes to achieve true health. Diet culture relentlessly bombards us with images and narratives that glorify a single, often unattainable body size and shape as the epitome of beauty and health. It tells us that in order to be happy, confident, and valued, we must conform to this ideal. Over time, these messages seep into our subconscious, leading us to believe that our bodies are inherently flawed and must be altered to fit the mold. As a result, we start viewing our natural bodies as problems to be fixed rather than incredible vessels deserving of love and care. This mindset fuels the myth that strict self-control and adherence to rigid food rules are the only pathways to achieving the elusive ideal body. In reality, this couldn't be further from the truth.

Diet culture has cunningly convinced us that the answer to our body insecurities lies in restriction and adherence to a myriad of food rules. Counting calories, banning entire food groups, or following fad diets have become the norm. But let's be clear… These methods are not sustainable, and they do not lead to lasting health or happiness. In fact, they often have the opposite effect. Restriction sets us up for a constant tug-of-war between our natural cravings and our willpower. The more we try to deny ourselves certain foods, the more we desire them, leading to inevitable binge-eating episodes and feelings of guilt and failure. This perpetuates the self-control myth, leaving us trapped in a cycle of self-doubt and frustration.

 

The Truth About Intuitive Eating

One of the foundational principles of Intuitive Eating is letting go of all the food rules. This means no more calorie counting, no more forbidden foods, and certainly no more guilt trips for enjoying in your favorite foods. Intuitive Eating encourages you to break free from these constraints and embrace the idea that all foods have a place in your life. Imagine a world where you no longer label foods as "good" or "bad," where a slice of cake holds the same value as a salad. This shift in mindset allows you to enjoy a diverse range of foods without the constant mental chatter about what you "should" or "shouldn't" eat.

As you proceed towards the journey of intuitive eating, it's natural to encounter moments where you may overeat or binge on foods you've previously restricted. It's common to fear that giving yourself unconditional permission to eat will lead to a loss of control. However, this initial sense of "loss of control" is a temporary phase. When you've spent years categorizing foods as forbidden, it's normal for your body to respond by craving them intensely when you finally allow yourself to have them. But as you continue to practice intuitive eating, this feeling will diminish. Think of it as a pendulum swinging from one extreme to another before finding its natural balance. With time, your body will learn to trust that it can have any food it desires, and this will result in a more relaxed and intuitive approach to eating.

The more you practice unconditional permission to eat, the less frequently you'll experience that overwhelming feeling of loss of control around food. Your body and mind will learn that no food is off-limits, eliminating the urgency to overconsume. The key here is patience and self-compassion. Breaking free from the diet mentality takes time, and it's perfectly normal to have moments of doubt along the way. But remember, Intuitive Eating is not about perfection; it's about progress.

In a world dominated by diet culture, it's no wonder we've come to believe that self-control hinges on rigid food restrictions. The myth that allowing ourselves to eat whatever we want, whenever we want, will result in a loss of all self-control is pervasive. However, when we peel back the layers and examine the science behind it, a different truth emerges. Habituation, the process of becoming less responsive to a frequently repeated stimulus, plays a pivotal role in Intuitive Eating. When you expose yourself to previously forbidden foods, their allure diminishes over time. Yet, diet culture has led us down a deceitful path, convincing us that our bodies must be smaller, and that the key to achieving this lies in restrictive eating and endless food rules. This couldn't be further from reality. Intuitive Eating encourages us to discard those oppressive food rules and instead listen to our bodies. As you start to pursue intuitive eating, you might initially find yourself overindulging in foods you've long restricted. The feeling of losing control can be unsettling. But the more you practice unconditional permission to eat, the less overwhelming that feeling becomes.

Ready to explore Intuitive Eating? Dive deeper into this transformative approach and discover how it can reform your relationship with food. To learn more about Intuitive Eating and receive expert guidance on your journey, click here to check out the program that will get you there Remember, your path to lasting wellness and self-confidence starts with trust in yourself and your body.

Previous
Previous

The Truth About Feeling Your Fullness

Next
Next

The Misconception: IE is Simply “Not Dieting”